October 04 / 19.15 Dundalk (AW)

19.15

Standard

Irish Stallion Farms EBF Star Appeal Stakes (Listed Race)

  • Prize money: £24369.57
  • 0m 7f 0y
  • 9 runners
RTV
View Course
Irish Stallion Farms EBF Star Appeal Stakes (Listed Race)

Runners: 9 runners

Type: Flat AW

Surface: Polytrack

Weather: Cloudy

8/1 (Won)

  • Win: £8.10
  • Place: £2.10

Form: 63331

Last run: 11 days

W: 9st 5lb

2 yo Colt

OR: 92

Form & Verdict
Twice placed in maidens before taking the same place in a 22-runner sales race at the Curragh; improved with the step up to 1m when scoring at Listowel; would get 15lb from stablemate Bernard Shaw in a handicap.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

1st

5

(5)

4th Oct 2024

Standard

0m 7f 0y

19:15 Dundalk (AW)

Right And True

9st 5lb

J: Ronan Whelan

T: A P O’Brien

soon led, headed but prominent after 2f, pushed along and led again 1f out, pushed out final 110yds

8/1

1st

2

(11)

23rd Sep 2024

Good To Yielding

1m 0f 0y

13:30 Listowel

Right And True

9st 6lb

J: Jack Cleary

T: A P O’Brien

prominent, went second after 2f, led and ridden over 1f out, ran on

9/4

3rd

3

(19)

15th Sep 2024

Good

0m 6f 63y

17:20 Curragh

Right And True

9st 5lb

J: Ryan Moore

T: A P O’Brien

in touch with leaders, headway and went third over 1f out, went second inside final 110yds, lost second towards finish

5/1

OUR TIP

7/2

  • Place: £1.80

Form: 41

Last run: 23 days

W: 9st 5lb

2 yo Colt

OR:

Form & Verdict
Made an encouraging debut when staying on for fourth of 19 behind the Aidan O'Brien-trained Ides Of March at the Curragh; that form has worked out well, and he did his bit to enhance it when readily landing the odds in a 6f Cork maiden; likely to be progressive.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

1st

5

(2)

23rd May 2026

Good To Yielding

0m 6f 0y

15:05 Curragh

Comanche Brave

9st 5lb

J: Ryan Moore

T: Donnacha Aidan O’Brien

Useful form at 7m/1m last season, fifth in the Irish 2,000 Guineas, third in the Jersey Stakes, odds-on for 7f Naas win; kept on for third in 7f Group 2 in Saudi Arabia in February; ran as well as could have been expected when fifth of eight behind the spectacular Ka Ying Rising at Sha Tin last month; trip possibly a little sharp for him.

5/1

3rd

7

(10)

13th Sep 2025

Soft

1m 0f 0y

16:55 Leopardstown

Comanche Brave

9st 5lb

J: Gavin Ryan

T: Donnacha Aidan O’Brien

Cork maiden winner last year and was gaining first win since when landing odds in minor Naas conditions event in July; highly tried at times, including smart form in both 2000 Guineas Trial over C&D and when beaten 5.5l in Irish 2000 Guineas; has been withdrawn due to soft ground before so ground unlikely to suit here.

7/1

1st

4

(4)

23rd Jul 2025

Yielding To Soft

0m 7f 0y

19:45 Naas

Comanche Brave

9st 8lb

J: Gavin Ryan

T: Donnacha Aidan O’Brien

Cork maiden winner over 6f last year; some fine runs in defeat in stronger company since, notably in Leopardstown 2000 Guineas Trial and Irish 2000 Guineas; below that form in the Jersey Stakes at Royal Ascot last time and has to rebound.

11/8

5/4

  • Place: £1.10

Form: 413 C

Last run: 20 days

W: 9st 5lb

2 yo Colt

OR: 107

Form & Verdict
$1.8 million yearling; promising fourth on Curragh debut, staying on well after being outpaced early; won a 1m maiden here in August by 9l; held his own when third of four as stable's second-string in a 1m Group 2 event at Leopardstown; blinkered now for what looks like a good opportunity despite a slight concern about the shorter trip.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

3rd

2

(9)

4th Oct 2024

Standard

0m 7f 0y

19:15 Dundalk (AW)

Bernard Shaw

9st 5lb

J: Wayne Lordan

T: A P O’Brien

dwelt start, midfield, good headway and led after 2f, headed 1f out, no extra inside final 110yds

5/4

3rd

1

(4)

14th Sep 2024

Good

1m 0f 0y

13:40 Leopardstown

Bernard Shaw

9st 5lb

J: Declan McDonogh

T: A P O’Brien

dwelt start, raced in third, led after 1f, 3 lengths ahead halfway, headed 1f out, no extra and lost second towards finish

4/1

1st

1

(7)

15th Aug 2024

Standard

1m 0f 0y

15:25 Dundalk (AW)

Bernard Shaw

9st 7lb

J: Wayne Lordan

T: A P O’Brien

prominent, soon went second, nudged along under 3f out, ridden to lead when edged right over 1f out, clear inside final furlong, pushed out towards finish

15/8

4th
1 (8)
Beckman

11/2

Form: 142

Last run: 56 days

W: 9st 5lb

2 yo Colt

OR: 96

Form & Verdict
20-1 debut Curragh 6f maiden winner; kept on into fourth of five behind the talented Hotazhell in the 7f Group 3 Tyros Stakes at Leopardstown in July; no match for the subsequent May Hill (Group 2) runner-up January in a Listed race at Tipperary; now meets January's stablemate Bernard Shaw on 11lb worse than handicap terms.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

1st

1

(2)

18th May 2025

Good

1m 0f 0y

15:02 Naas

Beckman

10st 0lb

J: Colin Keane

T: G M Lyons

Won a 6f Curragh maiden (good) on debut; has run creditably without winning in stakes company since; beaten 4.5l on first try at 1m in a listed race at the Curragh on seasonal comeback two weeks ago; should improve for that and not discounted on handicap debut.

100/30

1st

1

(2)

18th May 2025

Good

1m 0f 0y

15:02 Naas

Beckman

10st 0lb

J: Colin Keane

T: G M Lyons

Won a 6f Curragh maiden (good) on debut; has run creditably without winning in stakes company since; beaten 4.5l on first try at 1m in a listed race at the Curragh on seasonal comeback two weeks ago; should improve for that and not discounted on handicap debut.

100/30

2

(5)

5th May 2025

Good

1m 0f 0y

14:25 Curragh

Beckman

9st 5lb

J: Colin Keane

T: G M Lyons

Surprise debut winner of 6f maiden here last summer but bit exposed in stakes company afterwards, each time staying on as if a step up in trip will suit (not clear run at Dundalk final start); gelded over the winter and step up in trip should suit but others may have greater scope for improvement.

12/1

Form: 215 D

Last run: 48 days

W: 9st 0lb

2 yo Filly

OR: 94

Form & Verdict
Naas barrier trial winner; did well to finish a head second to subsequent Listed winner and Group 2 runner-up January at Gowran; comfortably landed 7f maiden at Leopardstown; faded after a brief spell in the lead from two furlongs won in a 7f Group 2 at Deauville in August.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

16th

4

(1)

24th May 2026

Good To Yielding

1m 0f 0y

17:05 Curragh

Va Va Vroom

9st 13lb

J: Robert Whearty

T: Gavin Cromwell

Out of form for Jessica Harrington last year; no sign of a revival in two runs this term; this looks too demanding.

25/1

10th

13

(9)

3rd May 2026

Yielding

0m 7f 0y

14:30 Cork

Va Va Vroom

9st 0lb

J: Robert Whearty

T: Gavin Cromwell

Maiden winner at two; struggled in handicaps in the first half of last season for Jessica Harrington and never counted on yard debut last October; not much better on reappearance.

20/1

12th

1

(17)

12th Apr 2026

Good To Yielding

1m 0f 0y

15:20 Leopardstown

Va Va Vroom

10st 3lb

J: Reese Holohan

T: Gavin Cromwell

Maiden winner here at 2 (good) but struggled in handicaps in first half of last season for Jessica Harrington and never counted on yard debut here in October on heavy; handicapper relenting but still on a high enough mark; wide draw a negative.

16/1

25/1

Form:

Last run:

W: 9st 0lb

2 yo Filly

OR:

Form & Verdict
Seventh foal; half-sister to Flat/hurdle winner Recoup; dam was a 1m Group 3 winner for Dermot Weld, sister to Group 1 winner Proportional; newcomer is thrown in at the deep end.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

6th

9

(11)

29th May 2026

Good

0m 7f 0y

17:40 Down Royal

Minaun View

9st 9lb

J: Adam Caffrey

T: Adrian McGuinness

Third runner for yard; maiden after 15 starts; one of her better runs when 3l third of 15 at Limerick (1m, yielding; one place behind Amemri) on penultimate; best work late on when fifth of 14 at Roscommon (7.5f, good) on latest; place shout.

14/1

5th

18

(2)

11th May 2026

Good

0m 7f 111y

17:53 Roscommon

Minaun View

9st 1lb

T: Adrian McGuinness

Third reserve; 0-14 but produced one of her better runs when a 3l third of 15 at Limerick on latest; dropped 1lb and nicely drawn if she gets a run; place shout.

3rd

4

(11)

25th Apr 2026

Yielding To Soft

1m 0f 50y

15:50 Limerick

Minaun View

9st 12lb

J: Jack Cleary

T: Adrian McGuinness

Maiden has run well in defeat several times for former yards up to 1m; moderate stable debut at Gowran (1m, soft) when 12l behind the winner; others preferred.

16/1

16/1

Form: 533355

Last run: 50 days

W: 9st 0lb

2 yo Filly

OR: 84

Form & Verdict
Has run creditable in several races won by Ballydoyle-trained rivals; however, well below her best here last time, when failing to stay 1m in the race won by Bernard Shaw; also held by Va Va Vroom on Gowran running.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

7th

7

(2)

16th Apr 2025

Good To Firm

0m 7f 0y

13:57 Gowran Park

Queens Fury

9st 4lb

J: Sam Coen

T: Adrian Murray

slowly away and awkward start, in rear

10/1

7th

7

(2)

16th Apr 2025

Good To Firm

0m 7f 0y

13:57 Gowran Park

Queens Fury

9st 4lb

J: Sam Coen

T: Adrian Murray

slowly away and awkward start, in rear

10/1

5th

5

(4)

7th Feb 2025

Standard

0m 7f 0y

18:00 Dundalk (AW)

Queens Fury

9st 3lb

J: Wayne Lordan

T: Adrian Murray

prominent, prominent behind clear leader after 2f, switched right over 2f out, soon weakened gradually

2/1

Form: 43

Last run: 10 days

W: 9st 5lb

2 yo Colt

OR: 80

Form & Verdict
Has made the frame in 7f maidens at Gowran and Listowel; unlikely to be good enough here.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

11th

7

(14)

18th Oct 2024

Standard

0m 7f 0y

18:15 Dundalk (AW)

Kahu

9st 6lb

J: Dylan Browne McMonagle

T: Joseph Patrick O’Brien

Made the frame in 7f maidens at Gowran and Listowel but looked in need of a step up in trip both times; out of his depth in Listed company over C&D latest; stable flying but plenty to prove from a wide draw.

14/1

8th

4

(1)

4th Oct 2024

Standard

0m 7f 0y

19:15 Dundalk (AW)

Kahu

9st 5lb

J: Declan McDonogh

T: Joseph Patrick O’Brien

prominent, weakened from over 1f out

25/1

3rd

3

(5)

24th Sep 2024

Good

0m 7f 15y

14:00 Listowel

Kahu

9st 7lb

J: Declan McDonogh

T: Joseph Patrick O’Brien

80,000euros yearling; also tongue tied on debut and was beaten just over 3l at Gowran (7f, good to firm), finishing fourth of 16; needs more here but that's feasible.

8/1

Form: 5816

Last run: 11 days

W: 9st 0lb

2 yo Filly

OR: 79

Form & Verdict
Long-priced 6f maiden winner at Navan for David Marnane; her new trainer continues to set the bar high following her sixth of seven in a 6f Listed race at Fairyhouse.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

8th

4

(6)

21st Jun 2025

Good To Soft

0m 7f 50y

Class 5

19:38 Ayr

Actin Like A Diva

9st 7lb

J: Amie Waugh

T: Jim Goldie

Poor results, without headgear, this season for new yard; could revive with cheekpieces refitted, having gained her Irish success (6f) in this headgear.

20/1

9

(6)

7th Jun 2025

Good

0m 5f 1y

Class 4

16:25 Musselburgh

Actin Like A Diva

8st 8lb

J: Amie Waugh

T: Jim Goldie

6f maiden winner in Ireland last autumn but has failed to beat a rival in two starts for Jim Goldie; like her two stablemates, she arrives here with risks attached.

25/1

14th

5

(9)

28th May 2025

Good

0m 6f 6y

Class 4

15:30 Hamilton

Actin Like A Diva

9st 6lb

J: Paul Mulrennan

T: Jim Goldie

6f maiden winner in Ireland but then disappointed in three runs for John McConnell and was tailed off on debut for this yard over 7f at Wetherby (50-1); others preferred.

50/1

+o+e Accumulators

Payout
Exacta €37.70
Straight Forecast €38.14
Trifecta €51.50

Selections

SPOTLIGHT:

Bernard Shaw

The Irish Sun:

Comanche Brave

RP RATINGS (IRE):

Bernard Shaw

TOPSPEED:

Bernard Shaw

POSTDATA:

Bernard Shaw