April 20 / 18.05 Thirsk

18.05

Soft

Happy 19th Birthday Lily Watkinson Handicap (Div I)

  • Prize money: £4187.2
  • 0m 6f 0y
  • Class 5
  • 13 runners
RTV
View Course
Happy 19th Birthday Lily Watkinson Handicap (Div I)

Runners: 13 runners

Type: Flat Turf

Surface: Turf

Weather: Partly cloudy

12/1 (Won)

  • Win: £10.50
  • Place: £3.10

Form: 40-776 D

Last run: 50 days

W: 9st 2lb

9 yo Gelding

OR: 68

Form & Verdict
This year's form-figures don't look especially enticing but he's much better on turf than AW; goes well at Thirsk and was runner-up to Society Lion in a division of this race 12 months ago (soft ground; off 6lb higher); one to take seriously with the cheekpieces (left off last time) returning.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

8th

11

(10)

26th Oct 2024

Soft

0m 7f 6y

Class 4

17:00 Doncaster

Cold Stare

9st 6lb

J: David Nolan

T: David O’Meara

9yo who needs to produce more than he's managed the last twice but before those he was a creditable fifth in the Ayr Bronze Cup and he's dropped to a dangerous mark; not written off.

14/1

5th

1

(8)

18th Oct 2024

Soft

0m 5f 217y

Class 5

13:52 Redcar

Cold Stare

10st 0lb

J: Jason Watson

T: David O’Meara

Most of his nine wins on soft or heavy; finished close up in the Ayr Bronze Cup last month and ran well enough to think he's still in reasonable form when fifth in a higher grade than this at Haydock last time; in the mix.

15/2

6th

10

(2)

28th Sep 2024

Soft

0m 6f 0y

Class 3

14:40 Haydock

Cold Stare

8st 13lb

J: Mark Winn

T: David O’Meara

Most of his nine wins on soft or heavy; finished close up in the Ayr Bronze Cup last weekend which gives him a fighting chance here but he has a better overall record on that track than this one and remains on much the same mark as when well adrift of Trilby here in April.

8/1

6/1

  • Place: £2.90

Form: 4256-3 D

Last run: 17 days

W: 9st 9lb

6 yo Filly

OR: 75

Form & Verdict
Ideally suited by 6f on ground softer than good; solid reappearance when a close third of ten at Catterick (Mersea second, Impressor fifth) 17 days ago and again unlikely to be far away.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

68

20th Sep 2024

Good

0m 6f 0y

Class 2

16:15 Ayr

Slainte Mhath

8st 13lb

T: Katie Scott

9th

2

(6)

4th Sep 2024

Soft

0m 6f 6y

Class 5

18:15 Hamilton

Slainte Mhath

9st 11lb

J: Jason Hart

T: Katie Scott

Gives her all and wasn't beaten far when fourth to Rock Melody over C&D (soft) in August; should be thereabouts again, although she holds no secrets from the handicapper and others appeal more for win purposes.

6/1

4th

4

(10)

13th Aug 2024

Soft

0m 6f 6y

Class 4

19:30 Hamilton

Slainte Mhath

9st 5lb

J: Sam James

T: Katie Scott

Very consistent in defeat earlier in the season (on ground ranging from good through to heavy) and she was beaten just over 1l when fourth of six over C&D (good to soft) last time; has won three times over C&D and every chance she'll be in the mix; the blinkers adopted last time are left off.

10/1

10/1

  • Place: £5.20

Form: 3123-5 D

Last run: 17 days

W: 9st 7lb

7 yo Gelding

OR: 73

Form & Verdict
Had a fine 2023, winning four times (5f/6f, soft/heavy); possibly needed the run when fifth at Catterick 17 days ago, and the usual cheekpieces return today; no surprise if he bounces back to form.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

7th

6

(1)

6th Nov 2024

Soft

0m 5f 8y

Class 4

13:43 Nottingham

Impressor

9st 4lb

J: Tom Kiely-Marshall

T: Phillip Makin

held up in rear on far side of group

8/1

7th

6

(1)

6th Nov 2024

Soft

0m 5f 8y

Class 4

13:43 Nottingham

Impressor

9st 4lb

J: Tom Kiely-Marshall

T: Phillip Makin

held up in rear on far side of group, outpaced 2f out, no impression

8/1

1st

2

(8)

18th Oct 2024

Soft

0m 5f 0y

Class 5

14:27 Redcar

Impressor

9st 10lb

J: Connor Beasley

T: Phillip Makin

Yet to strike this year but 5f on slow ground will suit and he's not handicapped out of things, for all that he'll be 2lb lower from the weekend; not ruled out.

12/1

Form: 34503- D

Last run: 203 days

W: 9st 7lb

4 yo Gelding

OR: 73

Form & Verdict
Just one win from 15 attempts; begins the season off his lowest mark and handles the mud, but he often blows the start and his stable has yet to strike this year; others appeal more.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

1st

7

(6)

5th Dec 2024

Standard To Slow

0m 5f 0y

Class 4

17:10 Chelmsford (AW)

Thankuappreciate

9st 5lb

J: Zak Wheatley

T: Declan Carroll

slowly away, towards rear

12/1

1st

7

(6)

5th Dec 2024

Standard To Slow

0m 5f 0y

Class 4

17:10 Chelmsford (AW)

Thankuappreciate

9st 5lb

J: Zak Wheatley

T: Declan Carroll

slowly away, towards rear

12/1

6th

7

(8)

12th Nov 2024

Standard

0m 4f 214y

Class 4

20:00 Southwell (AW)

Thankuappreciate

9st 4lb

J: Zak Wheatley

T: Declan Carroll

in touch with leaders

4/1

9/1

Form: -33741 D

Last run: 20 days

W: 9st 1lb

6 yo Gelding

OR: 67

Form & Verdict
Gained reward for his consistency over the winter when winning at Southwell (6f, AW) last month, and he's just as effective on turf; does not look overburdened by a 3lb rise.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

5th

6

(7)

28th Oct 2024

Standard

0m 6f 16y

Class 5

16:55 Southwell (AW)

Secret Road

9st 7lb

J: Marco Ghiani

T: Tristan Davidson

Two wins and a short-head second to his name in five runs over C&D following his victory off 4lb lower three weeks ago (first-time tongue-tie; well backed after a few ordinary efforts); this is tougher upped from 0-60 company.

5/1

5th

6

(7)

28th Oct 2024

Standard

0m 6f 16y

Class 5

16:55 Southwell (AW)

Secret Road

9st 7lb

J: Marco Ghiani

T: Tristan Davidson

Two wins and a short-head second to his name in five runs over C&D following his victory off 4lb lower three weeks ago (first-time tongue-tie; well backed after a few ordinary efforts); this is tougher upped from 0-60 company.

5/1

1st

4

(2)

8th Oct 2024

Standard

0m 6f 16y

Class 6

20:00 Southwell (AW)

Secret Road

9st 8lb

J: Clifford Lee

T: Tristan Davidson

Scored over C&D in March off 5lb higher mark; well held on his last three starts and a first-time tongue-tie is now attached to go with the regular hood; well handicapped but needs to show more.

10/1

16/1

Form: 1534-6 CD BF

Last run: 12 days

W: 8st 9lb

5 yo Gelding

OR: 61

Form & Verdict
Had productive 4yo campaign, winning three times including over C&D; might have needed most recent run after four months off but the pick of his turf form is on good to firm ground and soft conditions would be a worry.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

10th

12

(12)

9th Dec 2024

Standard

0m 5f 0y

Class 5

15:55 Newcastle (AW)

Rainbow Rain

9st 3lb

J: Tom Eaves

T: Tracy Waggott

prominent towards near side

8/1

10th

12

(12)

9th Dec 2024

Standard

0m 5f 0y

Class 5

15:55 Newcastle (AW)

Rainbow Rain

9st 3lb

J: Tom Eaves

T: Tracy Waggott

prominent towards near side

8/1

3rd

11

(2)

25th Sep 2024

Good

0m 5f 0y

Class 5

17:05 Redcar

Rainbow Rain

9st 4lb

J: Jason Hart

T: Tracy Waggott

started quickly, led at fast pace against far rail

10/1

OUR TIP

Form: 3074-0 CD

Last run: 104 days

W: 9st 9lb

7 yo Gelding

OR: 75

Form & Verdict
Won a division of this race in 2023 (soft ground) off today's mark; in and out since, but 7f probably stretched his stamina on his latest outing at Wolverhampton early in January; has to be respected if ready to roll after 104 days off.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

4th

1

(1)

22nd Oct 2024

Soft

0m 7f 3y

Class 4

16:10 Yarmouth

Society Lion

9st 13lb

J: Daniel Muscutt

T: Ed Dunlop

Acts on any ground; inconsistent this term apart from completing a double in May/June; however, he's 2-2 over this C&D and looks interesting back here.

7/1

6th

1

(6)

29th Sep 2024

Heavy

0m 7f 3y

Class 4

17:15 Epsom

Society Lion

9st 13lb

J: Daniel Muscutt

T: Ed Dunlop

Won two in a row earlier in the season (7f/1m, good to soft) and solid fourth at Kempton (7f, AW) last time; has won on soft and heavy ground in the past and might not be far away.

10/1

4th

8

(1)

20th Aug 2024

Standard To Slow

0m 7f 0y

Class 4

16:45 Kempton (AW)

Society Lion

9st 5lb

J: Daniel Muscutt

T: Ed Dunlop

in touch with leaders

10/1

Form: 8089-9 D

Last run: 11 days

W: 8st 6lb

7 yo Gelding

OR: 58

Form & Verdict
Most recent win, last spring, came off 7lb higher, and he probably needed the outing when ninth of 13 over C&D 11 days ago; handles the mud and may well be at concert pitch now; could be interesting at a price.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

4th

8

(1)

2nd Aug 2024

Standard To Slow

0m 6f 16y

Class 5

16:55 Southwell (AW)

Dandy Spirit

8st 7lb

J: Ray Dawson

T: Roger Fell & Sean Murray

Capable of running well but he's not as good as he was and is becoming hard to predict.

25/1

14th

12

(15)

21st Jul 2024

Good To Soft

0m 5f 217y

Class 6

16:27 Redcar

Dandy Spirit

9st 1lb

J: Jason Hart

T: Roger Fell & Sean Murray

Not as good now but is straightforward and arrives in form, having made a lot of the running off this mark at Newcastle last time; holds claims on that.

8/1

3rd

5

(8)

28th Jun 2024

Standard

0m 6f 0y

Class 6

20:20 Newcastle (AW)

Dandy Spirit

9st 6lb

J: Daniel Tudhope

T: Roger Fell & Sean Murray

Dual AW winner who went back-to-back on turf last spring and wasn't far away in two sprints before a lesser show at Thirsk last time; has a big run in him.

10/1

Form: 09734- CD

Last run: 194 days

W: 9st 6lb

4 yo Gelding

OR: 72

Form & Verdict
Sole win for Adrian Nicholls came over C&D in May 2022; ended last season with two respectable efforts on ground softer than good; has joined a stable that excels with sprinters; very dangerous if returning to his best.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

10th

10

(6)

22nd Mar 2025

Standard

0m 5f 0y

Class 5

20:15 Newcastle (AW)

Kings Crown

9st 0lb

J: Rhys Elliott

T: Michael Dods

It wasn't a strong Class 5 that he won here on March 1 and he ran just as well when third in a Class 4 nine days ago (Dark Kestrel second); others appeal more for win purposes.

7/1

3rd

7

(5)

13th Mar 2025

Standard

0m 5f 0y

Class 4

19:30 Newcastle (AW)

Kings Crown

8st 10lb

J: Rhys Elliott

T: Michael Dods

Two wins this year, the latest over C&D 12 days ago; that was a small-field Class 6, however, and he has more on his plate up 5lb against stronger opposition.

8/1

14/1

Form: 50063- D

Last run: 182 days

W: 9st 8lb

9 yo Gelding

OR: 74

Form & Verdict
Runner-up four times here and he begins the season on an attractive mark, but that's because he was 0-14 in 2023; no great record after an absence and others make more obvious appeal.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

10

(7)

16th Nov 2024

Standard

0m 6f 0y

Class 5

19:18 Newcastle (AW)

Music Society

9st 2lb

J: Cam Hardie

T: Tim Easterby

Ran on well to win a 6f handicap at Newmarket two weeks ago (6f, soft); that race had rather an end-of-season feel to it but the Topspeed figure was good and a 3lb rise looks fair; interesting on first AW start since October 2018.

7/2

9th

10

(7)

16th Nov 2024

Standard

0m 6f 0y

Class 5

19:18 Newcastle (AW)

Music Society

9st 2lb

J: Cam Hardie

T: Tim Easterby

Ran on well to win a 6f handicap at Newmarket two weeks ago (6f, soft); that race had rather an end-of-season feel to it but the Topspeed figure was good and a 3lb rise looks fair; interesting on first AW start since October 2018.

7/2

1st

12

(3)

2nd Nov 2024

Good

0m 6f 0y

Class 4

13:07 Newmarket

Music Society

8st 5lb

J: Cam Hardie

T: Tim Easterby

took keen hold early, towards rear, switched left when smooth headway over 1f out, ridden to lead inside final furlong, kept on well

9/1

14/1

Form: 07-320 D

Last run: 76 days

W: 9st 5lb

4 yo Gelding

OR: 71

Form & Verdict
Often misses the break, but that didn't stop him going close twice at Newcastle (5f, AW) in January; has had wind surgery (for the second time) since his latest poor run; relatively lightly raced but has enough to prove, including his ability to handle ground softer than good.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

3rd

1

(3)

22nd Mar 2025

Standard

0m 5f 0y

Class 5

20:15 Newcastle (AW)

Dark Kestrel

9st 9lb

J: Alex Jary

T: Antony Brittain

Ridden more prominently than usual (often slowly away) when second over C&D nine days ago; runs off the same mark and an apprentice takes off a handy 5lb.

5/1

2nd

5

(4)

13th Mar 2025

Standard

0m 5f 0y

Class 4

19:30 Newcastle (AW)

Dark Kestrel

9st 5lb

J: Cam Hardie

T: Antony Brittain

Hold-up sprinter; on a competitive mark and conditions aren't a problem but he will need the leaders coming back to him to win.

7/1

4th

4

(1)

4th Mar 2025

Standard

0m 5f 0y

Class 4

15:52 Newcastle (AW)

Dark Kestrel

9st 6lb

J: Cam Hardie

T: Antony Brittain

Usually misses the break, can pull hard and is drawn in an outside stall, which isn't a great mix; has enjoyed a highly consistent winter for all that but last year's two wins came off a 3lb lower mark and there will always be risks involved.

5/1

12th
7 (13)
Mersea

9/2

Form: 86-621 D

Last run: 9 days

W: 9st 5lb

4 yo Filly

OR: 71

Form & Verdict
Followed a fine second at Catterick (6f, heavy) by winning in a small field at Southwell (5f, AW; rallied gamely to lead again final strides) nine days ago; clearly in top form and should be in the thick of things again.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

3rd

5

(4)

11th Mar 2025

Standard

0m 6f 16y

Class 4

18:15 Southwell (AW)

Mersea

8st 10lb

J: Sean D Bowen

T: Grant Tuer

Returned from nine months off to spring a 50-1 surprise at Newcastle 12 days ago (6f; always prominent); up in class but taking on her own sex and might not have to work too hard to lead; respected.

100/30

1st

2

(2)

27th Feb 2025

Standard

0m 6f 0y

Class 5

14:45 Newcastle (AW)

Mersea

9st 9lb

J: Sam James

T: Grant Tuer

She wasn't at her best when last seen last May and there's a race-fitness question to answer; however, she's 1lb lower than when winning at Southwell (5f, Tapeta) in April and her trainer saddled one to finish second at 22-1 here recently following a similar break; not discounted.

14/1

5th

3

(5)

31st May 2024

Soft

0m 5f 212y

Class 5

21:00 Catterick

Mersea

9st 9lb

J: Connor Planas

T: Grant Tuer

pressed leader

10/1

Form: 3337-3 D BF

Last run: 27 days

W: 9st 4lb

6 yo Gelding

OR: 70

Form & Verdict
0-11 for current yard but has been placed several times, including when favourite at Doncaster (5f, soft) in March; second in a division of this race last year; leading contender.
Place /
No / Draw
Date / Going /
Distance / Class
Time + Course Horse + Weight
Jockey / Trainer
Verdict Starting price

6th

7

(3)

6th Nov 2024

Soft

0m 5f 8y

Class 4

13:43 Nottingham

Huddle Up

9st 4lb

J: Jason Hart

T: Jack Jones

towards rear

7/1

6th

7

(3)

6th Nov 2024

Soft

0m 5f 8y

Class 4

13:43 Nottingham

Huddle Up

9st 4lb

J: Jason Hart

T: Jack Jones

towards rear, outpaced 2f out, kept on final 110yds, never on terms

7/1

5

(5)

24th Oct 2024

Heavy

0m 5f 8y

Class 5

14:38 Nottingham

Huddle Up

9st 6lb

J: Hector Crouch

T: Jack Jones

5f-6f winner when trained in Ireland, including on heavy; placed in all four starts for this trainer but needs to pull out a bit more for a first British success.

4/1

+o+e Accumulators

Payout
Exacta £102.90
Straight Forecast £79.84
Tricast £1616.41
Trifecta £1623.20

Selections

RP RATINGS:

Slainte Mhath

POSTDATA:

Mersea

SPOTLIGHT:

King's Crown

NEWMARKET:

Society Lion

The Times:

Thankuappreciate

TOPSPEED:

Dandy Spirit

Telegraph:

Impressor

D Express:

Mersea

Daily Mirror:

Mersea

The Guardian:

King's Crown

The Sun:

Slainte Mhath

The Star:

Slainte Mhath

Daily Record:

Slainte Mhath

Daily Mail:

Society Lion